Heartbreak has swept through the Eureka Springs community after a beloved couple, 77-year-old Joy Bennett Willmeth and 71-year-old Robert Leo Willmeth, were found dead inside their home late Friday morning. What began as a routine welfare check quickly became a tragic scene that Carroll County deputies will not soon forget.
On November 14, 2025, the Carroll County Sheriff’s Office responded to a residence in the 3000 block of West Highway 62 following concerns from someone who had not been able to reach the couple. When deputies entered the home, they discovered both Joy and Robert deceased. Early findings revealed they each suffered fatal gunshot wounds— injuries starkly at odds with the quiet, peaceful life the Willmeths were known to live.
Arkansas State Police’s Criminal Investigation Division was immediately requested to lead the case. Authorities later confirmed that a suspect is in custody, though investigators have not yet released the individual’s identity or the possible motive behind the killings. Detectives say the investigation is active, and more information will be shared as details are verified.
As investigators work to piece together what happened inside the Willmeth home, the loss is deeply felt by neighbors, friends, and family members who described the couple as kind, gentle, and always willing to lend a helping hand. Their passing has left a painful void in a community that knew them not only by name, but by the warmth they brought into every interaction.
Joy and Robert’s bodies will be transported to the Arkansas State Crime Laboratory for autopsy to determine the official cause and manner of death— a formality that underscores the violent nature of their final moments. For loved ones, that reality is difficult to process. Many gathered in quiet remembrance upon hearing the news, recalling stories of a couple who spent decades building a life grounded in love, faith, and loyalty.
The home where they lived and loved is now a crime scene, and their futures— once bright with plans and routine— were taken in an instant of senseless violence. As the community mourns, officials ask for continued prayers and support for the Willmeth family.
About the Author
